doggone
Purple fan
Registered: 09-2003
Posts: 2293
|
Reply | Quote
|
|
MIJ vs Live In Stockholm 1970
Winning song gets 5.0. No ties allowed. I matched the same songs together instead of going in order of CD.
Speed King 5.0 Highway Star 4.9
Child in time 1970 5.0 CIT 1972 4.7
SOTW 5.0 Into the Fire 4.8
The Mule 5.0 Paint it Black 4.5
SKOW 5.0 Black Night 4.9
WTN 5.0 Lazy 4.9
Space Truckin 5.0 Mandrake Root 4.9
The Winner MIJ 34.5 LIS 1970 34.1
|
4/9/2005, 23:46
|
Link to this post
Send Email to doggone
Send PM to doggone
|
Rezi
Registered: 04-2004
Posts: 16629
|
Reply | Quote
|
|
Re: MIJ vs Live In Stockholm 1970
Speed King 5.0 Highway Star 4.9
Child in time 1970 5.0 CIT 1972 4.7
SOTW 5.0 Into the Fire 4.9
The Mule 5.0 Paint it Black 4.8
SKOW 5.0 Black Night 4.7
WTN 5.0 Lazy 4.7
Mandrake Root 5.0 Space Truckin 4.7
The Winner LIS 1970 34.4 MIJ 34
|
5/9/2005, 6:26
|
Link to this post
Send Email to Rezi
Send PM to Rezi
|
Apostate
Purple fan
Registered: 05-2005
Posts: 1843
|
Reply | Quote
|
|
Re: MIJ vs Live In Stockholm 1970
CIT I feel is better on LIS.
The version of Wring That Neck on LIS blows away "Lazy" from MIJ.
Overall as much as I LOVE both albums (haven't heard the In Concert version of CiT yet, MR. ED!!!), my favorite version of CiT remains on Powerhouse, as well as Wring That Neck and Speed King.
For SotW, check out In Concert or one of the other shows from the three '72 live Japan shows.
Made in Japan has THE take no prisoners versions of Highway Star, The Mule,and Space Truckin', though.
Highway Star, in particular, is worth the dozens of times I've lost MiJ and had to buy it all over again.
--- "Evil mind, lookin' down, without seeing at all."
|
5/9/2005, 14:08
|
Link to this post
Send Email to Apostate
Send PM to Apostate
|
MrEd45
Admin
Registered: 09-2003
Posts: 9983
|
Reply | Quote
|
|
Re: MIJ vs Live In Stockholm 1970
Speed King vs Highway Star = Highway Star
Child In Time (1970) vs Child In Time (1972) = Child In Time (1972)
Smoke On The Water vs Into The Fire = Smoke On The Water
The Mule vs Paint It Black = Paint It Black
Strange Kinda Woman vs Black Night = Strange Kinda Woman
Wring That Neck vs Lazy = Lazy
Space Truckin' vs Mandrake Root = Mandrake Root
...without even incorporating the 'points' system, "Made In Japan" wins 5-2.
--- " Those who can - do. Those who can't do - teach. Those who can't do or teach - administrate."
- Anon.
" One that will not reason is a bigot. One that cannot reason is an ignoramus. One that dares not reason is a slave." - Anon
|
5/9/2005, 15:55
|
Link to this post
Send Email to MrEd45
Send PM to MrEd45
Blog
|
Milan Fahrnholz
Purple fan
Registered: 09-2003
Posts: 17842
|
Reply | Quote
|
|
Re: MIJ vs Live In Stockholm 1970
Ignoring that weird points system as well, here goes:
Highway Star
CIT 1972
SOTW
The Mule
SKOW
Lazy
Space Truckin
A Made In Japan thing, as it looks like.
|
5/9/2005, 15:59
|
Link to this post
|
Gurra
Guitar Virtuoso
Registered: 10-2003
Posts: 1067
|
Reply | Quote
|
|
Re: MIJ vs Live In Stockholm 1970
Speed King vs Highway Star = Highway Star
Child In Time (1970) vs Child In Time (1972) = Child In Time (1970)
Smoke On The Water vs Into The Fire = Into The Fire
The Mule vs Paint It Black = The Mule
Strange Kinda Woman vs Black Night = Strange Kinda Woman
Wring That Neck vs Lazy = Wring That Neck
Space Truckin' vs Mandrake Root = Mandrake Root
A very close victory (4-3) for LIS it is.
--- "So you children of the world, listen to what I say
If you want a better place to live in spread the words today
Show the world that love is still alive you must be brave
Or you children of today are Children of the Grave."
|
5/9/2005, 19:25
|
Link to this post
Send Email to Gurra
|
Rezi
Registered: 04-2004
Posts: 16629
|
Reply | Quote
|
|
Re: MIJ vs Live In Stockholm 1970
quote: Milan Fahrnholz wrote:
Ignoring that weird points system
The point system is very logical and useful:
The song of a pair that you find better gets 5.0 points. Then you estimate how good the 'losing' song is compared to the winner: an example: SK gets 5.0. Highways Star? Oh, it's almost as good, I'll give it 4.9. Now, if the pair would have been SK, again scoring 5.0 against Razzle Dazzle, the latter had gotten, say, 2,5.
It's easy!
|
6/9/2005, 5:22
|
Link to this post
Send Email to Rezi
Send PM to Rezi
|
Rezi
Registered: 04-2004
Posts: 16629
|
Reply | Quote
|
|
Re: MIJ vs Live In Stockholm 1970
quote: MrEd45 wrote:
quote: Rezi wrote:
quote: Milan Fahrnholz wrote:
Ignoring that weird points system
a) The point system is very logical and useful
b) It's easy!
a) If we just substitute "arbitrary & subjective" for "logical" then we have something there! /
b) That it is!
Unfortunately it might lead to scandals like the Olympics have suffered in recent years. ( )
a) Every topic, especially on the Lists forum is arbitrary and above all, subjective. But I really like the point system in this topic, it gives a certain quasi-scientific quality to comparing LIS and MIJ!
b) Huh?
|
7/9/2005, 6:41
|
Link to this post
Send Email to Rezi
Send PM to Rezi
|